001124b domestic plans
001124c domestic plans
001124d domestic plans superimposed
011124a Wacko House 002 plans model 2285i03
011124b Goldenberg House partial model 2179i01
011124c Goldenberg House plans 2179i02
01112404 Housing for La Villette plans elevation axonometircs 231ai17
01112405 House for K.F. Schinkel model 2239i02
01112406 House for K.F. Schinkel axonometrics 2239i03
01112407 House for K.F. Schinkel plans elevations 2239i04
The Great Books (of Architecture)
Learning from Lacunae: a progressive inquiry of the acquisition of knowledge via reflection on what is not there
The Nimiety of Architecture: an abundance of redundance in architectural education, theory and practice
09112401 ICM Horti Argiani
11112401 St. Pierre at Firminy-Vert elevations (scaled 3.12) with Palais des Congrès 2189i06
I'm quickly reminded of a short passage I read last night--
--which seems somewhat related to your analogically jumping comment/question.
Schumacher's passage unwittingly describes subversive reenactment. Is subversive reenactment then a key ingredient of avant garde design? See how Le Corbusier subversively reenacts via re-interpretation, the Villa Savoye.
There's the new movie Lincoln, which tries very hard to be as close to the original as possible, and earlier this year there was the movie Lincoln, Vampire Slayer. Does (historical) fiction sometimes easliy fall into the category of subversive reenactment?
The logisital objective of a crime-scene reenactment is to reproduce the crime as closely as possible, and the aim of the reenactment is for the police investigators to gain a form of eye-witness experience of the crime. Reenactment within the philosophy of history has the same aim.
Perhaps subversive reenactment just happens to be a very good way to come up with something new again.
I would just caution that reenactment, revivalism and appropriation have relationships to each other, but they are not the same thing. Also, the negative aspect of Schumacher's quote is how hard he tries to deny that reenactment is part of Hadid's early design process.
Another example of Le Corbusier subversively reenacting the Villa Savoye is the upper half of the Governor's Palace designed for Chandigarh.
Actually, subversively isn't really the right term. Le Corbusier metabolically reenacts the Villa Savoye.
17112401 Museum of Architecture plan elevation model work 2245i15
17112401 OMA Forum Rotterdam
18112401 Steven Holl/Franklin Azzi Gare de Nord 2024 Paris
19112401 NE Philadelphia Arbor to Ridgeway base map data 2093i112