9 November

1729 birth of Charles de Wailly
1778 death of Giovanni Baptista Piranesi

1812 birth of Paul Abadie, the Younger

reenactment
1999.11.09 10:28     2759a 2907 2909a 3749b 3792d 3811q 4016g 4017m 4555 5140 5025 5026 5027 5045 5060 531a 5900s

manifesto replay
1999.11.09     3784e

27 October 312
2000.11.09     0312

9 November 312 or 318
2000.11.09     8210c

inconsistencies and hyperboles?
2000.11.09     3728c 3739b 3747 3777b

calendrical coincidence
2001.11.09 12:49     2070

ur-archaelogical architecture
2001.11.09 20:12     4018c

Pohlsander, coincidentally
2001.11.09 21:02     8210h

It rocked Eisenman on his chair...
2007.11.09 10:56     e2524 e2540 e2678a e2682 e2776 e2914 e2985 3727e 3768b 4700r 5051 5300k

Quondam's Fifteenth Anniversary
2011.11.09 15:36     3331g 3331h
2011.11.09 15:36     3331g

Why won't you design what we (the public) want?
2013.11.09 11:11     3749y 3771i
2013.11.09 15:57     3747n

Herzog & de Meuron   MKM Museum Küppersmühle Extension   Duisburg

Ecosistema Urbano   Banyan Hub   West Palm Beach




Scena Rustica or Scena Satirica

1999.11.09 10:28
reenactment
Again thanks for you comments/critique. If reenactment as a design prescription is still only a "weak hypothesis," your consideration of the notion so far certainly contributes supplemental vitality and strength.
The evocation of Serlio's 'street scenes' is indeed apt--the notion of stage set is very much part of reenactment, i.e., the place upon which and within which to 'act' again (and again). For the record, Serlio drew three scenes, the third, Scena Rustica or Scena Satirica, is all natural/naturalistic (proto-primitive hut? or proto-romanticism?).
While reenactment certainly necessitates a contextual understanding, reenactment as a design paradigm is nonetheless not necessarily site specific. For example, theme parks everywhere are for the most part far removed for the 'actual' themes they reenact. On the other hand, the reenactments within Venturi (Rauch) and Scott Brown's Franklin Court (Philadelphia), Western Plaza (Washington D.C.) and Welcome Park (Philadelphia) relate directly to their respective sites/environments. Reenactment then can (and indeed does) have it both ways in terms of context.

As to the "problem" of "exciting ideas" never getting developed due to being brightly spotlighted and then quickly moved on from, perhaps this 'trendy' behavior too is a form of reenactment, that is, a repetitious renewal, the continual process of putting on a new hat, but always putting on a hat nonetheless.
The best philosophy I've read so far that purports reenactment is within Collingwood's The Idea of History. Collingwood is much influenced by Croce, and Croce is much influenced by Vico.
When I first began to redraw Piranesi's Campo Marzio using CAD, I was doing so to get as close to Piranesi as possible; essentially, I was reenacting his act of drawing as best I could. For me, this exercise, this reenactment, has provided enormous insight albeit it took several years of continual work for this vision to develop. I am certainly not Piranesi, nor do I contend to possess his superior creative talent and imagination, but I deliberately attempted to do some of the same things he has done, and in so doing I honestly believe I removed several degrees of separation. Perhaps reenactments then are always a play with degrees of separation, sometimes seeing how close one can get to the 'original' and/or sometimes seeing how far one can "stretch the truth," to name the extreme cases.

12110901 IQ01   2402i13
12110902 IQ02   2175i09 2392i102
12110903 IQ03   2309i02 2392i103
12110904 IQ04   2092i06 2392i104


2013.11.09 11:11
Why won't you design what we (the public) want?
One of the saddest things about this whole thread is the overall passivity of both sides. And one of the greatest ironies is that the 'traditionalists' want change and the 'modernists' want things to stay as they are.
What's lacking from this 'argument' is the role of mediation (starting with the printed image through to the digital) and its effect on what people like/want.


15110901   Herzog & de Meuron   MKM Museum Küppersmühle Extension   Duisburg


16110901 German Pavilion plan plan elevation section images attached   2152i02
16110902 Analusian Houses walls opaque   2451i05


17110901 ICMS07 plans 4400x2200   2110i124
17110902 ICMS08 plans 4400x2200   2110i125


18110901   Ecosistema Urbano   Banyan Hub   West Palm Beach



««««

»»»»


0312 2607a 4711d c0613
www.quondam.com/c11/1109.htm

Quondam © 2019.11.18